It could be a long autumn ahead for Match of the Day…

Alan TyersSun, August 23, 2026 at 5:10 AM UTC

0

There is unrest at the BBC about the future of Match of the Day

Match of the Day has been under scrutiny this week after reports that its big-name analysts have fallen out with Alex Kay-Jelski, the beleaguered BBC Sport supremo.

Alan Shearer and Micah Richards will be appearing less this season, preferring instead to focus on their lucrative podcast with Gary Lineker, and the programme will therefore hand punditry opportunities to less familiar figures including Toby Alderweireld, Robbie Keane, Ashley Young and Thomas Frank.

Factor in the hosting triumvirate of Mark Chapman, Gabby Logan and Kelly Cates being used on rotation and it is reasonable to wonder how the Saturday night staple will foster a sense of continuity or momentum with a constantly changing cast.

Mark Chapman, Kelly Cates and Gabby Logan have impressed as hosts - Charlie Clift

Saturday night’s season opener, however, looked like business as usual – at face value anyway. Chapman hosted with a pair of England striker greats in the shape of Alan Shearer and Wayne Rooney, there was some analysis, some banter, and a few talking points.

The problem is that you cannot build on this opener and, given the disappointing World Cup the BBC had, the critics will be watching for any slip-ups.

After his former club’s dreadful efforts against Hull, Chapman teased Rooney about his new audio venture: “Do you think it’s a good time to launch a new Man United podcast? I’m just asking for a friend…”

Shearer chipped in: “They’ve got some good rivals, haven’t they?”

Chapman: “We’ll stick to football.”

Advertisement

I think it is poor form for Shearer to be puffing up his non-BBC ventures while on the BBC (albeit in mild and humorous terms). After all, were it not for the licence fee payers he would not have anything like the sort of post-career broadcast profile he enjoys.

The BBC is in safe hands with the likes of Alan Shearer and Wayne Rooney - BBC

Nevertheless, he is entitled to work where he wishes and it is a loss for the BBC that people it has invested a lot in are now able to build their own competitor. Who knows, maybe Lineker and co will ultimately bid for the highlights rights to the Premier League.

The Match of the Day brand demands familiar faces with A-list credentials, strong opinions and a few laughs: some of the roster for this season just are not quite big enough figures.

With Shearer and Richards stepping back, it leaves quite a lot of pressure on Rooney. He has several good qualities as a pundit but still comes across as a little nervous sometimes and he does have a tendency to garble his words.

He had first crack at the debrief of the opening match but rather than offer a strong opinion about Manchester United, he instead talked the viewer through half a dozen clips. “He’s passed it here… and then he’s moved there, which means that there’s a gap here” and so on. That’s fine as it goes but we can all see the pictures.

Wayne Rooney has let nerves get the better of him at times - Michael Regan - The FA

Rooney seems at his most comfortable when he’s in conversation with someone else, and especially so when he can draw on his comparatively recent and vast and rich playing experience to tell you what the players might be thinking or feeling. This is a matter for the show’s producers to find a role for him that best uses his talents.

While Shearer may be a loss, it should be said that he was bang average as a pundit for many, many years and it was only when Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher raised the bar that he improved. So there is reason to suppose that Rooney can develop.

Chapman as ever remains excellent company on telly and radio alike and will do the job well with whoever they put him with, but, much like a football club at the start of the season, it takes a while to bed in new signings and it could be a long autumn ahead for Match of the Day.

Original Article on Source

Source: “AOL Entertainment”